Love Locks – Love or Hate?

I was surprised recently to read an article about the campaign to stop Love Locks being added to bridges in Paris.

The padlocks, engraved or bearing a written message of love between two people, are locked on to bridges around the city. The locks originated on the Pont des Arts and Pont de l’Archevêché but have spread to many picturesque river spots in the city, with an estimated 700,000 Love Locks in place.

Pont de l’Archeveche courtesy of TripAdvisor

The gesture of attaching a lock and throwing away the key as a symbol of unbreakable love has become a bone of contention as a love/hate war breaks out between the romantics and the campaigners.

The ‘Free Your Love, Save Our Bridges’ message is being spearheaded by two American ladies, Lisa Anselmo and Lisa Taylor Huff, who feel the locks have become an eye sore on beauty spots. The campaigners, who both live in Paris, are not feeling the love for this particular style of gesture and are calling for a ban, labelling Love Locks as an “epidemic” which amounts to vandalism. They hope to reclaim the historic bridges to allow people to fall in love with the beauty of the view, not the rusting locks.

I was in Liverpool last weekend and took some photos of the Love Locks on the Albert Dock because it’s the first time I’d really noticed any in the UK. The padlocks are chained to railings along the waterside and have been building up slowly. While it’s nowhere close to the scale of the locks attached to the Pont des Arts, I found the locks really interesting and was moved by some of the heartfelt engravings.

Loves of Love by Sara Hardman Travels

Locks on the Albert Dock, Liverpool

It’s not solely a wall of fun for couples spontaneously buying a lock and scrawling over it with a marker pen to be part of a craze. Many of the locks were engraved with tributes to loved ones; clearly they were locked with dignity, ceremony and deep meaning to the key holder. I would imagine that the families who took the time to create this public tribute would be heartbroken to think they could be removed for impacting upon the river view – in the event such a campaign gathered momentum in the UK.

Should that make a difference or are the Parisian campaigners right? Should beauty spots be left to be enjoyed in their natural state because the locks are spoiling the view and, in the case of the Pont des Arts, in danger of becoming so heavy that they damage the structural integrity of a bridge?

Locks of Love by Sara Hardman Travels

The collection builds slowly in Liverpool

I can see both sides of the argument. From a distance the beauty of a location like the Pont des Arts is compromised by a wall of multi-coloured locks and messages but when you pick out one individual lock, hold it in your hand and read someone’s personally written message, would you have the heart to remove it?

 

  • You can see more about the official campaign here – No Love Locks

 

Advertisements

8 thoughts on “Love Locks – Love or Hate?

  1. I actually saw these when I was in Paris and thought it did spoil the view slightly. There was so many that they all piled on top of each other and you can’t really read the messages any more. Also people were going even further and adding bike locks and really huge padlocks. Love your close-up photo.

    1. Thank you, I wished I’d taken a few more when I saw the article in the Guardian and then the big internet campaign. Bike locks don’t sound very romantic! 🙂

  2. Like you Sara I can see both sides of the argument. When I first heard of these happening a few years ago I completely felt it was vandalism.

    Now I see it more and more, most recently virtually a whole bridge in Melbourne over the Yarra River covered in them. I can see the intent, emotion and symbolism of placing one of these locks somewhere.

    Ultimately though the locks are being placed by people onto something which is not theirs and they have no claim or right over. If the council/bridge owners want to remove them then effectively the people who placed the locks have no rights to make them stay.

    I appreciate the emotional and loving gesture of these locks around the world but they are simply gestures. They do not guarantee any permanency.

    1. It’s difficult isn’t it? Having seen a photo of the Pont des Arts in 2003 – before the locks were added – they have, in my opinion, spoilt the view of the area.
      Like many things, when you judge from a distance you get an overall view but when you pick out one individual of that group and get a personal insight, your perspective is affected.
      It’s hopeless. I’m still on the fence!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s